Manual versus Automatic Transmission: Which is Better?

Posted on by Defensive Driving | in Car Stuff, Cool Driving, Defensive Driving Online

 
gear-lever
 
Since the inception of automatic cars, there has been an ongoing debate over the merits of a vehicle with an automatic transmission, or a traditional manual transition. Certainly every driver has their preference, and there are pros and cons of each. We have weighed out the good and bad of buying each kind of transmission–read on to learn more about them.

Manual

Pros:
–Can be Cheaper
This is not a hard and fast rule when it comes to price, but as most Americans are not comfortable driving a stick shift, a car with a manual transmission can often be found for less than an automatic–especially if it is used. They are sometimes cheaper to maintain, for example manual transmission fluid doesn’t deteriorate as quickly as automatic transmission fluid.
–More Power
A lot of car enthusiasts love the added power, especially during acceleration, that comes with a manual transition.
–Fuel Economy
Because of the nature of a stick shift, fuel economy is often much better than with an automatic transmission, especially as clutch control can prevent as much braking and acceleration.
Cons:
–Harder to Find
There is no question that manual cars are a lot harder to find, especially since improvements have been made to automatic vehicles to make them more reliable. And because of their scarcity, they can become difficult to find–especially when looking for a used car.
–Potential Extra Repairs
Though manual cars can be cheaper to repair, it is often the automatics that will be more reliable in the first few years of life. Often as a result of the wear and tear from inexperienced drivers, the clutch can receive quite a bit of wear, and burn out.
–Learning to Drive Stick
If you did not learn how to drive in a manual car, you might find it difficult to pick up, and it will take some patience.

Automatic

Pros:
-Hands off Driving
Obviously “hands off” is not meant literally, but there is certainly a lot more multitasking when it comes to driving stick. An automatic is a much more leisurely experience.
–Is No Longer a Lesser Vehicle
When automatic cars were first available, they were often seen as less reliable and more prone to problems than the alternative. Now however, they are every bit as reliable as manuals.
–More Options
As previously stated, manuals are more widely available in the USA. There are also more options for the average car owner if you are looking for an automatic.
Cons:
–Not as Much “Control”
Car lovers often prefer the amount of control that comes with a stick shift, and can find it frustrating that an automatic does not allow one the ability to change gear at will.
–Sometimes Unavailable
If you are looking for a vehicle such as a sports car, certain models are not actually available with an automatic transmission, taking the decision out of your hands anyway.

Which do prefer? Manual or automatic? Let us know on Facebook!

|

Customer Reviews

Defensivedriving.com has a ShopperApproved rating of 4.7 based on 123219 ratings and reviews.

Harleigh Sumrow united states
Easy and simple so far
Amber Brown Texas , united states
Very helpful
Miguel Teveni None, united states
quick and easy
Kathryn Johnson None, united states
quick and easy so far
Sheldon Hardwell Texas, united states
Easy to understand
Michael Thomas None, united states
Quick and easy
Jaime Barrera None, united states
Easy.
Jerome Parker II None, united states
great
Rhonda Hernandez None, united states
Easy to register and able to compete course in my available time .
Luis Sanchez None, united states
Good
Tania Saleem Tx, united states
Good
Kevin Guevara Texas , united states
Great experience, good courses
ELIZABETH S ETHERIDGE None, united states
fast easy to follow..
Francois Newkirk Texas , united states
Everything went good.
OSCAR ROMO None, united states
awesome
Maryam Shishesaz None, united states
It was great
Karen Coursey None, united states
Quick and easy sign up
Colby Forster Texas, united states
Used it before. Simple and straightforward
Kristi Geishauser Tx, united states
Great so far
Jasmine Redeaux Texas, united states
Very hands on, it explained everything from beginning to end, I would highly recommend.
Luis Ordaz None, united states
nice course
Vidal Hinojosa None, united states
quick
Tihomir Krtalic Texas, united states
Perfect
Mark Anthony Morales Texas, united states
Great service
Hayden Cooke None, united states
Great and easy
See all reviews on shopperApproved.com
Why DefensiveDriving.com
  • 20 Years in Business
  • Over 2 Million Customers Served
  • Highest Possible Better Business Bureau Rating
  • Award Winning Course