Supreme Court Gets It Wrong With Its DUI…

Posted on by Defensive Driving | in Defensive Driving Tips

Missouri’s push to more easily draw blood from people suspected of driving drunk failed to convince U.S. Supreme Court justices Wednesday.

Law enforcement must continue to seek warrants to take blood from drivers stopped for possibly driving impaired, the court ruled in a case that originated in southeast Missouri.

More than 30 other states and the Obama administration had joined Missouri in asking justices to give officers almost complete discretion in drawing blood samples without a warrant.

The Supreme Court held that police usually must try to obtain a search warrant from a judge before ordering blood tests for drunken-driving suspects.

In their 8-1 ruling, justices sided with a Missouri man who had been subjected to a blood test without a warrant and was found to have nearly twice the legal limit of alcohol in his blood.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote for the court that the natural dissipation of alcohol in the blood is generally not sufficient reason to dispense with the requirement that police get a judge’s approval before drawing a blood sample.

The case stemmed from the Oct. 3, 2010, arrest of Tyler McNeely in rural Cape Girardeau County.

A state trooper stopped McNeely after he observed his car speeding and swerving. McNeely, who had two previous drunken-driving convictions, refused to submit to a breath test to measure the alcohol level in his body. He also failed several field sobriety tests.

The arresting officer, Cpl. Mark Winder of the Missouri Highway Patrol, said McNeely’s speech was slurred.

Winder did not attempt to get a warrant but drove McNeely to a hospital, where a technician drew his blood. McNeely’s blood alcohol content was 0.154 percent, well above the 0.08 percent legal limit.

After a circuit court threw out the test results, the Missouri Supreme Court upheld that action, saying that the blood test violated the Constitution. Police need a warrant to take a suspect’s blood except when a delay could threaten a life or destroy potential evidence, the Missouri court added.

Justice Mayor failed to list “the natural BAC  level.” which is .02…supposedly

The system isn’t a flawless one; however, both victims and DWI offenders have navigated these rules for justice for years. While I feel the punishments could be more severe for DUI offenders, the process of due process endorsed by the Supreme Court is an over reach. The process we currently have shouldn’t be turned upside down.  She failed to verify that in her decision.

 

The “natural” alcohol content in humans is .02 or under. Justice Sotomayor’s view,

and rises every hour for drinking alcohol’.  Not anywhere the suggested eight hours of

drinking in this case. The court’s ruling is flawed.

 

Doris Aiken, Founder/President

RID USA, inc.

|

Customer Reviews

Defensivedriving.com has a ShopperApproved rating of 4.7 based on 113114 ratings and reviews.

Rosalinda Orta Tx, united states
quick and easy
Krystal Jackson united states
Quick registration and a plethora of information
Randy Page Jr united states
Good experience
Katy TX, United States
Its easy and informative!
Emir Nasufi None, united states
amazing
Warrick Walker-Williams None, united states
Super easy
Robert Harrell None, united states
Great
Tatum Tx, united states
Awesome
Laila Williams Texas , united states
It was good and easy
Dan TX, United States
Very engaging
Isaias Pesina united states
Helpful
Lauren Taylor Texas, united states
Good experience overall
John Bates TX, united states
Easy to follow instructions.
chloe stevens united states
It's been an easy and cheap experience!
Jose Rodriguez united states
It was quick, easy and very user friendly
Jonathan Ruvalcaba None, united states
Everything is easy
Cole Yarbrough None, united states
So far it’s been a smooth process
Melanie Kaiser None, united states
quick and easy
Sabrina Narvaez None, united states
Great
Kelli Ashton None, united states
it has been fast
John Heath None, united states
Straight Forward
Jennifer Medina None, united states
easy
Samuel Ibarra None, united states
Love it
ryan kempisty united states
easy
See all reviews on shopperApproved.com
Why DefensiveDriving.com
  • 20 Years in Business
  • Over 2 Million Customers Served
  • Highest Possible Better Business Bureau Rating
  • Award Winning Course